Should
I Say I've Been Drinking?
One of the cardinal rules when dealing with the
police is to be cooperative up to a point. You do not have to
say anything to the police until you speak to your attorney. You
will however be required to take a number of tests to determine
if you are intoxicated. Under California law, you may decline
these roadside tests, but, refusal to take the test may result
in a stiffer penalty than if you took the test and failed. Some
would argue that you would be able to better fight the conviction
if the test were refused. You would still lose your license for
refusing the test. Your best defense is to ask to speak with an
attorney. Do not say anything else. The police will ask you questions
repeatedly, just answer that you would like to speak with your
attorney. The information contained in this message is general
and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed
attorney.
The
Right to an Attorney When Asked to Take a Field Sobriety Test
Under California law, you may refuse a Field
Sobriety test, but are not entitled to consult with an attorney
before taking them. This could work to your advantage depending
upon the circumstances of your drinking. It could also work against
you. You must make a decision to either take the test or refuse.
You must decide immediately with or without your attorney present.
Unless the attorney was riding with you, you will likely have
to make the decision without their advice. You do not have the
right to a change of heart if you should refuse and later decide
that you don't want your license suspended for that refusal. In
the state's eyes, the decision is made. If you are being transported
to the facility to have your blood tested then you will gain some
time to decide. The information contained in this message is general
and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed
attorney.
What
is the Officer Looking for at the Scene
If you have been pulled over for any reason,
the police officer will be alert to any sign that you have been
drinking. If they see any container, even old ones in the rear
seat, they may suspect that you have been drinking. They will
notice that your eyes are glassy and red. They will also be able
to smell alcohol on your breath. There is no breath mint or home
remedy that can stop the odor of any alcohol. It may be a minty
fresh spearmint alcohol smell, but it is alcohol none the less.
The officer will also look for slow reaction time and slurred
speech. If you are asked to exit the vehicle, the officer will
note any difficulty walking or general lack of coordination. At
this point you may be asked to perform several challenges to determine
your ability to operate a motor vehicle. And finally, you may
be asked to perform a blood alcohol test. All of this information
will be used by the state to make their case. The information
contained in this message is general and should not substitute
for the advice and counsel of a licensed attorney.
Field
Sobriety Tests
If you are stopped for suspected drunk driving,
the officer on the scene may ask you to perform a series of tasks
to determine your ability to operate a motor vehicle. Among the
tests that might be performed is the typical "walk and turn"
test. This test involves walking a straight line heel to toe without
stumbling. You may be asked to extend your arms, close your eyes
and bend your head back and then touch your nose with your fingertip.
You may also be asked to recite the alphabet. Other tests involve
the involuntary responses the body makes when under the influence.
The officer may shine a flashlight into your eyes to see how fast
the pupil dilates. In some jurisdictions, field sobriety tests
are often filmed by a camera mounted in the patrol car and may
be used against you in a court of law. The information contained
in this message is general and should not substitute for the advice
and counsel of a licensed attorney.
The
Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus or Penlight Eye Test
The penlight eye test is a simple physical test
to determine if you are impaired. The officer will shine a penlight
into your eyes and ask you to track the movement of the light
with your eyes without moving your head. If you are impaired,
your eyes will have difficulty following the light smoothly. If
the eyes begin to jerk before they reach an angle of 45 degrees,
then it is likely that you are impaired, but it is not a certainty.
Police Officers frequently administer this test poorly and administering
the test properly requires excellent training and good conditions
for an accurate reading. The test is not considered proof of intoxication
in many states and is often only used to indicate if the subject
should be given a blood test. More than likely the test will be
only one of several possible field sobriety tests you will be
asked to perform. The information contained in this message is
general and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of
a licensed attorney. For a Free Consultation,
What
If I Don't Agree to Take a Field Sobriety Test?
Recent Supreme Court rulings have allowed the
police to force you to take a blood test if they feel the need,
but in practice, force is rarely used. Instead, California has
developed punitive laws that may cause you to lose your license
for a longer period if you refuse the test than if you take it
and fail. In California, you may be asked to make an immediate
decision about taking the blood test. A refusal will result in
a 1 year suspension or revocation. Some people believe that fighting
a DUI is easier if you refuse the test, but that will depend on
many factors. The information contained in this message is general
and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed
attorney.
A
Choice of Chemical Tests
In California, the arresting officer must tell
you that you have the right to choose between different types
of tests for alcohol. This usually means the choice between a
Chemical Breath test, or a blood test. You will probably be given
a series of field sobriety tests, such as walking a straight line
and reciting the alphabet before being asked for a more scientific
analysis. In some states you will be asked to perform a breathalyzer
which measures gases in the breath. These results are susceptible
to numerous problems, including false positives from people with
diabetes and those who have worked with volatile chemicals. If
you are offered a choice of tests, it is generally agreed that
blood tests are the most accurate. If you have had only one drink,
a breath test will show an immediate result and the police may
let you go. The information contained in this message is general
and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed
attorney.
No
Miranda Warning: Case Dismissed?
Will your case be dismissed if the police fail
to read you your rights? Probably not. The Miranda rule was initiated
to prevent police from intimidating defendants under questioning.
If you are not, then you will still be prosecuted if the prosecution
feels there is enough material evidence without the information
elicited by police questioning. Then there is the problem of proving
that the police did not do something. Proving a negative is very
difficult. Plus, if you are found to be impaired, you may be read
your rights and you may say that you understand your rights, but
you may not remember the fact. In short, do not rely upon a failed
Miranda warning to get you off the hook. The information contained
in this message is general and should not substitute for the advice
and counsel of a licensed attorney.
Charged
With Two Crimes
In an effort to expand their anti-drunk driving
arsenal; California has enacted separate laws that prohibit both
driving with a level over point zero eight (.08) and driving under
the influence. This enables the prosecution to still charge you
with a crime if your driving abilities were not apparently impaired
as is required when charged with driving under the influence.
Example: You and your buddies are out for a drive. You are stopped
and test out at over the legal limit of point zero eight (.08).
Your sober buddies testify that your driving was not impaired.
You may still be prosecuted for the mere act of driving with a
blood alcohol level of point zero eight (.08). You can still argue
that the test was inaccurate, or that the officer was improperly
trained in order to counter that charge. The information contained
in this message is general and should not substitute for the advice
and counsel of a licensed attorney.
License
Revoked and Notice of Suspension
In California, there are two ways of losing your
driving privileges. The first is a suspension. This is the lighter
of the two. It means that the state has temporarily withdrawn
your right to drive. There is a fixed period in which the license
is suspended and upon successful fulfillment of all of the court's
requirements, the license is reinstated. A revocation of a license
is the removal of the right to drive without automatic reinstatement
at the end of a specific period. It is usually permanent until
after a certain period of time when you may apply for a new license.
The circumstances of the revocation may come into consideration
when you reapply for your license. The California Department of
Motor Vehicles will hold an administrative hearing before your
license is revoked. The information contained in this message
is general and should not substitute for the advice and counsel
of a licensed attorney.
Can
I Represent Myself?
While it is possible to represent yourself in
a drunk driving case, it is not recommended. There are many complex
issues involved in a successful defense, many of which are technical
in nature and require considerable training. This is particularly
true in a DUI case, requiring an attorney with special training
in DUI Defense. Knowledge of court procedure is also crucial to
an effective defense. An attorney will have the advantage of experience
with the various judges who might try your case. While lady justice
is blind, the judge isn't. Every judge is different. If you have
prior offenses, an attorney might be able to strike a prior if
certain requirements are fulfilled. Again, this is a highly technical
move and requires experience. If you should make it to trial,
an attorney will be highly experienced in the jury selection process
and will make the appropriate peremptory challenges. The information
contained in this message is general and should not substitute
for the advice and counsel of a licensed attorney.
Punishment
for Drunk Driving
California has a different set of punishments
for the same offense. You can be sure that the punishment will
increase for every conviction. A first conviction may include
probation and a license suspension for as little as 30 days. If
you refuse a blood alcohol test, you may be punished more than
if you had taken and failed the test. In some cases, the punishment
is twice that of a DUI conviction. For a second and third offense,
the number of days the suspension is in effect increases. Your
license may be revoked. If a fatality results from an accident
in which the driver at fault is found to be legally intoxicated,
then the driver may be charged with a felony requiring mandatory
jail time. The information contained in this message is general
and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed
attorney.
Driving
One of the requirements in California, is that
the person in the car actually be driving the car. If there is
any question as to who it was in fact driving, there may be room
for reasonable doubt. The police will try to establish at the
scene who was driving. If they pull up behind a car and actually
see who is driving the car, then there is little doubt that the
driving defense will not work. Many people think that if they
can only outrun the police and make it home, they can act innocent.
This is a mistake with potential disastrous results. If you do
run and then are caught, you will only compound the charges and
the penalty against you. And, more importantly, you will endanger
the lives of innocent people. Never try to evade the police. The
information contained in this message is general and should not
substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed attorney.
Miranda
An acquittal due to failure to Mirandize, or
read you your rights, is often the fare of television courtroom
dramas, but the truth is such an occurrence is rare. Police officers
are trained and retrained in proper procedures involved in an
arrest. Each officer carries a Miranda card from which they will
read, even if they feel they have memorized the warning. Even
if you feel you were not properly read your rights or that they
were forgotten altogether, the case will not be thrown out. Only
the information gathered by direct questioning by the police prior
to reading the warning will be unusable. Failure to Mirandize
is usually not the best defense in a drunk driving case. The information
contained in this message is general and should not substitute
for the advice and counsel of a licensed attorney.
Implied
Consent Warnings
The main principle behind the state's right to
ask for a chemical test to determine your blood alcohol level
is the implied consent law. It states that anyone with a driver's
license automatically consents to testing. No one has the absolute
right to operate a vehicle. Every state has an implied consent
law. Supreme Court rulings have decided that police may forcibly
take your blood in order to test your blood alcohol levels, though
on a practical level, that rarely happens. Most states rely on
statutes that make refusing to test even more punishing than taking
the test and failing. In California, you make a choice between
the type of test you wish to take. Many experts agree that the
least accurate is urinalysis. If this test is available, be sure
to ask for it. If the facility only has blood testing, then you
must use that type of test. The information contained in this
message is general and should not substitute for the advice and
counsel of a licensed attorney.
Under
the Influence
"Under the influence" means that your
judgment and physical ability to operate a vehicle are impaired.
In some states, in order for one to be convicted of driving under
the influence, the state must prove that you were incapable. If
your passengers testify to your sobriety and independent witnesses
testify that you did not appear to be under the influence, then
the state's case will be more difficult to prove. This will be
especially true if your blood alcohol level is just above the
legal definition for intoxication. If your attorney can raise
doubts about the validity of the test itself, the persons administering
the test or other technical problems in combination with your
apparent sobriety, then the state may be hard pressed indeed to
make its case. The information contained in this message is general
and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed
attorney.
Blood
Alcohol Concentration
Blood alcohol concentration is the percentage
of alcohol that is in the blood at the time of testing. This is
the key. In many states, your blood alcohol levels must be at
a certain level at the time you were driving. There are several
types of tests: breath analysis, urinalysis and blood analysis.
The most accurate test is the blood analysis, yet it can have
many problems with accuracy. Due to the variance between people's
metabolisms, one level may mean a different level of impairment
than another. The prosecution realizes these variances and generally
wants a blood alcohol level significantly above the legal level
of intoxication. If the accused did not appear to be intoxicated,
the accuracy of the test may be challenged. There are many other
technical reasons for challenging the blood alcohol test. In other
words, it is not written in stone. The information contained in
this message is general and should not substitute for the advice
and counsel of a licensed attorney.
A "Rising
BAC" Defense?
The human body is slow to absorb alcohol into
the system. If you drink three fast drinks and then get into a
car, your blood alcohol levels at the time you are actually driving
may be below the level that the state considers legally intoxicated.
But after you are stopped, you may spend an hour being transported
and processed before taking a blood test. By this time, the blood
alcohol level has risen to a legal definition of intoxication
though you are no longer driving a vehicle. If witnesses at the
scene testify that you did not appear to be under the influence,
that is, you were not impaired, then the prosecution will have
a difficult time proving that you met the legal definition of
impairment. The information contained in this message is general
and should not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed
attorney.
Testing
During the Absorptive Phase
The absorptive phase is the period when the body
is actively absorbing alcohol into the bloodstream. Alcohol is
absorbed in the stomach, the upper intestine and the lower intestines.
The rate of absorption is the highest while in the upper intestine.
In about one hour, ninety percent of the alcohol will have been
absorbed into the bloodstream.
The rate of absorption varies considerably from
individual to individual. It also will vary according to the contents
of the stomach at the time drinks are ingested. If you are tested
during the absorptive phase, then the results of the test may
be inaccurate. As there are many technical issues involved in
blood alcohol testing-all of which can be challenged in court,
an attorney with specialized training in DUI Defense will most
likely be your best advocate. The information contained in this
message is general and should not substitute for the advice and
counsel of a licensed attorney.
Retrograde
Extrapolation
One of the fancier methods the prosecution and
the law uses to determine your blood levels at the time you were
driving is retrograde extrapolation. This is a mathematical calculation
of what your blood alcohol levels must have been when you were
driving, given its current levels. This type of calculation is
often made when blood alcohol levels, at the time of testing,
are lower that expected. It is used to suggest that your levels
must have been higher when you were driving. Because everyone's
metabolism is different and because the amount of food in your
system can change the rate of absorption, retrograde extrapolation
is very suspect. It is important to challenge such suppositions.
The information contained in this message is general and should
not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed attorney.
DUI
Ticket and Insurance
Because of computerization of records and the
ever increasing number of laws designed to combat drunk driving,
the likelihood that an alcohol related ticket could escape your
insurance company's notice is dwindling. In some cases, your company
may not notice your ticket for some time. If they do not have
a regular review process or the state does not have an automatic
notification law on the books, you could simply not say anything
and hope for the best. Just be sure to renew on time and make
no changes either in carrier or in the policy itself. If your
company does find out, they may drop you either immediately or
at the end of your policy term. If you cannot get insurance from
another carrier, then you may be able to use your state's high-risk
pool. The rates are very high and the coverage basic, but it will
let you keep your license. The information contained in this message
is general and should not substitute for the advice and counsel
of a licensed attorney.
Avoiding
a Drunk Driving Charge
Avoiding a drunk driving charge is the easiest
thing in the world. Don't drink and drive. Is it that hard? Get
a friend to be the designated driver. Take a cab to where you
plan to spend the evening and leave in a cab. Some cities have
instituted special fare cabs or even free cab rides to help cut
down on the death and suffering that drunken driving causes. If
you are stopped by the police, and are found to be intoxicated,
they will take you in. If there is some doubt that your were actually
impaired or you know that you had only a couple of drinks then
there may have been an error made while testing your blood alcohol
concentration. They may not have followed proper procedure or
the device may not have been calibrated correctly. You may have
a different metabolism, or if you are diabetic, you will often
give a false positive reading. There are many reasons why they
may be in error, and you should not be punished for their mistake.
The information contained in this message is general and should
not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed attorney.
Should
You Get a Lawyer?
The defense of a driving under the influence
charge is a difficult and technical undertaking. There are many
advantages an attorney experienced in this type of law can bring
to the case. If you are arrested and do not get an attorney, you
will be at the mercy of the authority's decision making process
from the beginning to the end. If during the course of an investigation,
there are irregularities, things that could cause the charge to
be thrown out, it is certain the police, prosecution and court
system will not tell you about it. You may never know that the
irregularity even happened. If you have prior convictions for
drunk driving you should definitely consider an attorney. They
know how to ask that priors be stricken, thus possibly lessening
the punishment should you be convicted. Without a lawyer, most
DUI's are convicted. The information contained in this message
is general and should not substitute for the advice and counsel
of a licensed attorney.
Your
First Court Date
Your first court date will be an arraignment
where you will enter a plea of either guilty, not guilty or no
contest. Remember, you can always change your plea later to guilty
or no contest. It will not be necessary for you to have an attorney
present at the arraignment, though it would probably be wise.
If you cannot afford an attorney, it is at the arraignment that
such issues are discussed. The court will either appoint an attorney
or will give you a financial disclosure form that you can fill
out and take to the Public Defender's Office. It is important
to fill out the form correctly or you may be charged with perjury,
a very serious crime. If you are found to have the ability to
pay for an attorney, you will be required to pay for the legal
services of your Public Defender. If you have not already arranged
bail, the court will probably release you on your own recognizance,
unless this is not your first appearance or it is a felony charge.
You will also be given an opportunity to ask for a jury trial.
The information contained in this message is general and should
not substitute for the advice and counsel of a licensed attorney.
Entering
a Plea
Entering a plea is easy at the first court date-not
guilty. Why not guilty? Because you can always change your plea
later to guilty or no contest. When you enter this plea, you will
need to clear up other business. If you do not have an attorney
at this time, you may ask the judge for additional time to speak
with an attorney. After you enter your plea of not guilty, your
attorney can investigate the facts of the case and speak with
your prosecutor about a plea bargain of it seems to be the best
course. Your attorney may even recommend that you plead guilty
or no contest, if the facts warrant. But if there is any reasonable
doubt to be found in this case, then your attorney will make every
effort to win your case. The information contained in this message
is general and should not substitute for the advice and counsel
of a licensed attorney.
Legal
Consequences of DUI
The legal consequences of a conviction for drunk
driving are often severe and getting worse with each passing year.
Punishments are different in every state, but all usually involve
suspension of your license and at least probation. The length
of the suspension and probation a first offense can range from
a few days to a year. The second conviction means tougher penalties,
longer suspensions and even revocation of your driver's license.
Revocation means that your license will not be automatically reinstated.
You will need to apply for your license. In California, you may
not reapply for a certain period of time. If your insurance company
finds out about the conviction, your insurance rates may skyrocket.
They may even drop your coverage altogether. The information contained
in this message is general and should not substitute for the advice
and counsel of a licensed attorney.